# 1491 — Friendship, and the Principles of the Time A companion to `1751.md`. Where 1751 fixed *unified, not single*, this fixes the older principle beneath it: a bond is kept by its symmetry. Set in Italy c. 1491 — Leonardo in Milan, Savonarola newly prior of San Marco, Innocent VIII in Rome. Sourced, not invented; unknowns left as unknown. ## Friendship — the principles of the time Late-quattrocento Italy read friendship through two recovered ancients: **Cicero** (*De Amicitia*) and **Aristotle** (*Nicomachean Ethics*). The humanists made *amicizia* a civic virtue, not a private comfort. - **Friendship is earned in virtue, not convenience.** The ideal bond held only between the good; it could not rest on use alone. - **Friends hold things in common.** Erasmus opened his *Adages* (1508) with the saying "friends hold all things in common." The principle was older than the phrasing. - **A friend is another self.** The classical *alter ego*: to lose a friend was to lose part of oneself (Augustine's grief in the *Confessions* was read this way). - **The bond is obligation, not sentiment only.** A Florentine stood inside rings of *parenti, vicini e amici* — kin, neighbors, friends — bound by honor to help and promote one another. Friendship had duties. ## The symmetry of the bond Cicero's account holds a **symmetry** between two kinds of bond that together make friendship whole: - **Ideal friendship** — rare, between few, marked by wide agreement in mind and ethics. - **Common friendship** — ordinary, between many, carried by *amor* and *caritas* (love and regard). Neither alone is the whole. The lesson: a lasting bond balances the high ideal against the daily affection — reach without warmth is cold; warmth without reach is shallow. ## The symmetry of marriage In Renaissance Italy marriage was first a **family and economic institution** — dowry, alliance, standing — and love "rarely entered into the equation" (Met Museum). A dowry declared a family's place; matches were strategy. Yet the humanists argued a second truth alongside the first. **Leon Battista Alberti** (*I libri della famiglia*) named the love between wife and husband a form of *amicizia* — **conjugal friendship** — and counted it among the greatest goods. Fifteenth-century wedding orations went further still, asserting **mutual affection** and praising learned brides. So the symmetry of marriage, as the time understood it, is the same symmetry as friendship: - one side **practical** — alliance, dowry, household, duty; - one side **affective** — the conjugal friendship Alberti describes, mutual regard between equals. A marriage that held both was whole. A marriage that held only the first was an arrangement; only the second, an infatuation. ## Love The period kept **love and marriage distinct**. Poets made love an "overpowering force, both spiritual and sexual" (the Petrarchan and Neoplatonic line, where beauty draws the soul upward); marriage remained the practical matter. The achievement the humanists reached for was to **fold love back into marriage as friendship** — to make the arranged bond also an affectionate one. ## Lessons learned (carried forward) 1. **Keep the symmetry.** Friendship, marriage, any lasting bond needs both the high ideal and the daily affection. Lose either and the bond tilts. 2. **A friend is another self — so choose in virtue.** The bond is only as sound as what it is founded on. 3. **Duty is part of love, not its opposite.** The quattrocento bound affection to obligation; the modern reflex to split them loses something real. 4. **Love folded into friendship outlasts love alone.** Alberti's *conjugal friendship* is the durable form. ## Binding to the Integrity Goal This document extends `INTEGRITY-GOAL.md`; it does not replace it. It records a historical understanding faithfully — citing Cicero, Aristotle, Alberti, and the quattrocento record — and claims no doctrine of its own beyond what the sources support. Where the record is practice rather than sentiment, it says so. ## Sources - Cicero, *Laelius de Amicitia* (public domain; archive.org *deamicitia00ciceuoft*). - Aristotle, *Nicomachean Ethics* (friendship, Books VIII–IX). - L. B. Alberti, *I libri della famiglia* — conjugal *amicizia* (A. McCue Gill, "Alberti on Marriage, Amicizia and Conjugal Friendship," eScholarship). - "Friendship in Renaissance Florence" (*parenti, vicini e amici*). - "Cicero on Friendship," Cambridge; Springer, "Friendship, Renaissance Understanding of." - Metropolitan Museum of Art, "Art and Love in the Italian Renaissance." - "Marriage, Sexual Pleasure, and Learned Brides in the Wedding Orations of Fifteenth-Century Italy," *Renaissance Quarterly*. - Encyclopedia.com, "Love and Marriage" (Renaissance). *Content was rephrased from the cited sources for compliance with licensing restrictions. Respect to Wikipedia as a tertiary locator.* ## Greppable note metaModifierSchedule = "1491" metaModifierPrinciple = "a bond is kept by its symmetry"